Too much of a good thing?
Despite the fact that some species of plants need the heat from a fire to propagate, too many fires can actually be bad for them. Take the example of the banksias mentioned above. If another fire sweeps through before the new plants have had a chance to reach seed-producing age then that species won't be able to replace itself with another generation. It's going to be the end for that species in that area.
Poor soils
Australia has the poorest soils of any continent on the planet. That's because the volcanism, mountain formation and glaciation that creates new soils happened such a long time ago. In many parts of Australia the topsoil layer is very thin or doesn't even exist at all. There are very few nutrients left in it.
When a fire sweeps through the bush, the wind carries nutrients away as particles in the smoke, to wash down in the rain into rivers or the ocean. So every time a bush fire burns a patch of the Australian bush it might be helping some species of plants to breed, but it's also making the poor soils a tiny bit poorer.
What about the critters?
If a fire burns slowly enough, and if it doesn't generate enough heat, then many animals can often escape from a fire. Like the banksias mentioned earlier, some animals can even benefit from fire. For example, wallabies like to nibble on the green shoots that spring up out of the charred ground in the weeks after a fire. All that fresh new growth everywhere can even lead to some animals increasing in numbers.
Unfortunately not all animals do okay in a fire. Koalas can suffer horrible burns. If they survive the fire then they can face the problem of their food supply being burnt out. And while they're wandering along the ground looking for a new food tree they're vulnerable to attacks by dogs.
So some animals can do okay with fires and others don't do so well. But if the fire is a very hot, powerful fire, then almost every animal in its path has a very bad chance for survival.
Hot fires
It sounds odd to talk about 'hot fires' just like it sounds weird to talk about 'cool' fires. Surely all fires are hot aren't they? But when fuel levels build up enough the flames are able to reach the middle and top parts of the trees. That's when you get an especially dangerous fire - much hotter, much faster and much more destructive than the aborigines' mosaic burning.
Eucalypts (gum trees) can be especially dangerous in one of those 'hot fires.' That's because of the eucalyptus oil they produce. On high-temperature days the oil vapourises into the surrounding air, sometimes even giving a blue haze to the distant hills. That blue haze is what gave the Blue Mountains area, west of Sydney, its name. The blue haze might be pretty but it can be explosive during a fire, and cause whole gum trees to burst into flames ahead of the fire front.
Those hot fires burning all the way to the top of the trees are sometimes called crown fires. Crown fires are nasty fires. They often move too quickly for animals to escape and they can be so destructive, burning with such extreme heat, that nothing survives in their area at all. I remember one night as a teenager watching a crown fire burning a couple of miles from where I lived. The fire was so intense it was sending explosions of flame hundreds of feet above the trees, like glowing mushroom clouds. A week later I visited the area and was shocked to see that even the large old trees had vanished – leaves, branches and thick trunks all gone. There was nothing left but a field of grey ash. It was like the surface of the moon.
Fires which are as intense as that do much more damage than good to the environment and put wildlife, plants, housing and people at risk.
To sum up
People often say that fire is good for the Australian bush. It's true that after a 'cool' fire the Australian bush recovers quickly and that proper fire management is important. But we shouldn't make the mistake of thinking every fire in the Australian bush is a good thing. |